Developing FM
An ergonomics guide to office seating PDF Print E-mail
Written by Levent Çaglar, Senior Consultant Ergonomist, FIRA International, 2008   

The most ergonomic office chairs exceed the minimum criteria specified by safety regulations to contribute to the wellbeing and efficiency of the workforce. Levent Çaglar of FIRA International offers some advice and guidelines for making the optimum choice in office seating.

  • What are the main requirements for good seating?
  • How can you identify ergonomic chairs that go beyond minimum heath and safety requirements?

People are spending more and more time sitting down. A lot of leisure time is spent on a sofa watching TV, reading or eating; travel involves sitting in cars, coaches, trains or planes; and at work, many workers sit for much of the time, and with the advent of the electronic office, people perform more tasks in the same seat.

All this means there is a need for the design and selection of ergonomic seating.

What is good seating?


Ergonomically correct and comfortable seating should provide stable body support in a variety of postures over a period of time.

It should also be appropriate to the tasks or activities that may be performed by the person sitting on the chair. The main requirements for good seating are that:
  • Circulation in the thighs is not restricted;
  • The posture requires little muscular effort to maintain;
  • The stress on the spine is minimised;
  • Without over-riding any of the above requirements, the design of the workplace, furniture and task should encourage a certain amount of movement and changing of posture.

How does the task affect the choice of chair?


In a work environment, chairs should not be considered in isolation but in conjunction with the work surface, because the chair should suit both the height of the workstation and the needs of the user.

The distance between the seat and work surface should be 210-300mm, whilst maintaining at least 170mm between the underside of the work surface and the seat.

Ergonomic and comfortable seating depends mainly on what the person sitting in the chair will be doing. In general, the work people do in offices falls into two main categories: multi-task or dedicated-task work.

Multi-task work


As the name suggests, multi-task work involves carrying out a number of different tasks, some of them simultaneously.

Multi-task workers generally move around a great deal in their offices. They might be reading, writing, using a computer, answering a telephone, accessing a number of documents on and around the workstation and having meetings with other people.

In ergonomics terms, multi-task work is almost ideal, because constant changing of tasks makes the adoption of different postures essential.

Changing posture allows muscles to alternate between tension and relaxation, and allows spinal discs to compress and decompress.

This encourages blood flow and hence prevents any build-up of pressure on buttocks, legs and backs.

Therefore a multi-task chair should allow body movements whilst maintaining good support, especially for the lower back.

Dedicated-task work


Dedicated-task work is usually highly repetitive and requires the worker to sit in a relatively fixed posture for extended periods. Such workers are deskbound and normally carry out a single task.

A good example of this would be call centre workers. As a task becomes more dedicated, the person becomes less and less able to move.

Dedicated-task work causes certain muscles to work continuously (in order to keep the body upright).

It also reduces blood circulation to insufficient levels at which it becomes difficult to eliminate the accumulated lactic acid during continuous muscle contraction.

There is some clinical evidence that such physiological effects of dedicated-task work contribute to back problems among office workers.

There is nothing worse than having a chair with numerous complicated controls that either users do not bother with or adjust incorrectly.

A comprehensive user manual for the chair is needed, and should explain the use of the controls and illustrate how to achieve good, appropriate and comfortable postures.

In addition, workers should be given training to ensure they are familiar with the controls for each adjustment appropriate to the tasks they need to perform.

Regulations


The Display Screen Equipment (DSE) regulations affect today's office workers. These were introduced in 1992 by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) to implement the so-called European VDU directive, and were revised in 2003 to include laptops, but there have been no changes regarding chairs or desks.

DSE regulations have a number of minimum requirements with which all equipment, including chairs and desks, must comply.

The schedule to the DSE regulations state the following requirements for a chair in use at a DSE workstation:
  • The work chair shall be stable and allow the user freedom of movement and a comfortable position.
  • The seat shall be adjustable in height.
  • The seat back shall be adjustable in both height and tilt.
  • A footrest shall be made available to any user who wishes one.

These are very general, but HSE's accompanying guidance document states:

"The primary requirement here is that the work chair should allow users to achieve a comfortable position. The schedule requires the seat to be adjustable in height (i.e. relative to the ground) and the seat back to be adjustable in height (also relative to the ground) and tilt.

“Provided the chair design meets these requirements and allows the user to achieve a comfortable posture, it is not necessary for the height or tilt of the seat back to be adjustable independently of the seat. Automatic backrest adjustments are acceptable if they provide adequate back support."

HSE guidance also states that the equipment (including chair and desk) that complies with the requirements of BS EN ISO 9241 will meet the requirements of the regulations. It also refers to dimensional and safety standards, which are listed below.

Checklist/selection criteria


  • Dimensional requirements as in BS EN 1335 Part 1.
  • Ergonomic requirements as in BS EN ISO 9241 Part 5.
  • Safety requirements as in BS 5459 Part 2 (for people weighing up to 150kg and for up to 24 hours' use) or BS EN 1335 Part 2 (for people weighing up to 110kg and only up to 8 hours' use);
  • Appropriate flammability standards.

Chairs meeting these standards will only fulfil minimum requirements of the regulations. Compliance with the above standards is only the starting point in the selection of a good office chair.

The following guidelines should help you to identify good ergonomic chairs that go beyond the minimum requirements of the regulations.

Such chairs should improve the wellbeing and efficiency of the workforce and should eliminate or minimise the occurrence of musculoskeletal disorders and possible subsequent litigation and costly compensation:
  1. Check if you have very short or very tall people or people with special needs, especially chronic back pain sufferers; they would invariably need different chairs as they would be outside population range of requirements of the BS EN 1335 Part 1.
  2. Chair should allow users to move (not fidget) and adopt different postures.
  3. Chair should encourage dynamic postures.
  4. Chair should recline with good back support and at all recline positions i.e. the back should not lose contact with the backrest.
  5. If the backrest reclines more than 25-30° from the vertical and users are likely to adopt such postures for some time, a neck rest is essential.
  6. Tension of the backrest should be adjustable to suit body weights of your intended users so they can recline without being pushed forward or falling backwards. Ideally this adjustment should be automatic, but manual adjustments are acceptable provided they can easily be reached and adjusted.
  7. A few degrees of forward tilt is good and opens up the angle between thighs and the trunk. This is beneficial for better breathing hence more oxygen for the brain and muscles, consequently alert attentive workers etc.
  8. Armrests should not prevent getting close to the desk, either by being able to be lowered below the desk or being able to slide backwards.
  9. Both seat and backs should be firm but soft - not so hard as to cause discomfort, but not so soft that buttocks feel the hard base of the seat.
  10. All the controls should be easily identifiable, reachable and operable.
  11. Instruction leaflet or a CD should be clear, concise and easily understood. Being able to store video demonstration of chairs on the intranet is a good usability aid.

Any selection process should include user trials. Having identified three or four chairs by the above process, these chairs should be tried at least for a week by the staff at their workstations.

A carefully designed questionnaire should be administered. Analysis of these questionnaires would pinpoint the chair that matches the needs of your workforce, the tasks they carry out and also the ones they like.

Levent Çaglar is Senior Consultant Ergonomist at FIRA International. Please visit www.fira.co.uk
 
< Prev   Next >